What to Keep in a Sex Toy Box (and What Not To)

• Lube and cleanliness are non-negotiable. The best sex toys work better, feel better, and last longer when paired with the right lubricant and proper cleaning.

• Consent and communication shape great experiences. A sex toy box should support ongoing conversations, boundaries, and shared exploration.

• Intentional choices beat impulse buys. A well-curated sex toy box focuses on body-safe essentials that encourage pleasure, comfort, and curiosity.

A sex toy box isn’t just storage—it’s a reflection of how you approach pleasure. Whether you’re shopping for sex toys online for the first time or refining a collection of the best sex toys for your body and relationships, what you keep (and what you skip) matters.

At its best, a sex toy box supports exploration without pressure, communication without awkwardness, and pleasure without unnecessary risk. That means centering consent, choosing quality over quantity, and—most importantly—never overlooking lube and toy hygiene.

Let’s break down how to build a sex toy box that’s playful, practical, and pleasure-positive.

The Foundation: Consent, Communication, and Exploration

Before we talk about products, let’s talk about people.

Every sex toy box—whether it’s just for you or shared with partners—should be grounded in three core principles:

Consent

Consent isn’t a one-time checkbox; it’s an ongoing conversation. Every toy, activity, and fantasy belongs in the “yes” category only when everyone involved genuinely wants it.

Your sex toy box should never feel like an obligation. Toys are invitations, not expectations.

Communication

Toys often open doors to new sensations—and new questions. Clear communication helps you:

• Share boundaries

• Express curiosity

• Adjust in the moment

A quick check-in like “Do you want to try this?” or “How does that feel?” can transform a good experience into a great one.

Exploration

Exploration thrives in low-pressure environments. The goal isn’t performance—it’s presence. A thoughtfully stocked sex toy box encourages experimentation without judgment, allowing preferences to evolve naturally over time.

What to Keep in a Sex Toy Box

1. Lubricant: The Real MVP

If there’s one item every sex toy box should prioritize, it’s lube. No exceptions.

According to sexual health educators, lubricant improves comfort, reduces friction, and can make sex safer and more pleasurable for people of all bodies and ages. Lube isn’t just for dryness—it’s for sensation, confidence, and ease.

Why lube matters so much:

• Reduces irritation and micro-tears

• Enhances sensation and glide

• Makes toys feel more natural and comfortable

• Supports longer, more relaxed play

Water-based lubricants are especially sex-toy-friendly and versatile, making them a staple in any collection.

Featured Lubes

Wicked Sensual Aqua (Water-Based Lubricant)

• Lightweight, silky feel

• Latex friendly

• Non-sticky, easy to clean

Wicked Sensual Aqua is a reliable, everyday lube that enhances sensation without distraction. It’s an excellent choice for beginners and seasoned toy lovers alike, offering smooth glide with minimal residue.

Sliquid Naturals H2O

• Glycerin- and paraben-free

• Long-lasting hydration

• Designed for sensitive bodies

Sliquid H2O is ideal for anyone who wants a clean, body-conscious formula. It delivers dependable slip while keeping ingredients simple and skin-friendly.

Pro tip: Keep lube visible and accessible in your sex toy box. If it’s easy to reach, you’re more likely to use enough—and that’s always a good thing.

2. Sex Toys Made From Body-Safe Materials

The best sex toys are the ones you trust.

Look for:

• Medical-grade silicone

• Stainless steel

• Glass

These materials are non-porous, easier to clean, and safer for long-term use.

When shopping for sex toys online, prioritize retailers that clearly list materials and care instructions. If a product is vague about what it’s made of, it doesn’t belong in your sex toy box.

Featured Products:

Bang! Thrusting and Sucking Rabbit Vibrator

• Made from phthalate-free and body-safe silicone

• 2 speeds and 8 patterns to choose from

• Double-satisfying with G-spot targeting and clit-sucking

The Bang Thrusting and Sucking Rabbit Vibrator delivers both internal and external stimulation with a playful twist. Its thrusting function mimics natural motion while the suction-style clitoral stimulator adds an extra layer of sensation — perfect for explorers who want more than just vibration

Triple Spire Tapered Silicone Anal Trainer Set

• Three tapered trainers for gradual, comfortable progression

• Smooth, body-safe silicone that feels soft and easy to glide

• Perfect with water-based lube for added comfort

• Tapered design makes insertion intuitive and approachable

Curious about anal play but not sure where to start? The Triple Spire Tapered Silicone Anal Trainer Set makes exploration feel confident and comfortable. With three graduated sizes, it lets you ease into new sensations at your own pace — perfect for beginners and seasoned pros who love gentle progression.

3. Toy Cleaner (Because Clean Toys = Better Sex)

Cleaning your toys isn’t optional—it’s essential.

Sex toys come into contact with sensitive areas, and bacteria can build up quickly if they aren’t cleaned promptly after use. Regular cleaning:

• Helps prevent infections

• Protects your body’s natural balance

• Extends the life of your toys

• Keeps shared play safer

Experts consistently recommend cleaning toys immediately after use, even if you plan to use them again soon.

Featured Cleaner

Foaming Smart Sex Toy Cleaner

• Alcohol-free, gentle formula

• Safe for silicone, rubber, and plastic

• Fast, no-fuss application

Foaming Smart Toy Cleaner makes post-play cleanup quick and approachable. Its easy pump and fast-drying foam help turn hygiene into a habit—not a hassle.

Keeping a toy cleaner inside your sex toy box reinforces the idea that pleasure and care go hand in hand.

4. Smart Storage Solutions

How you store your toys affects their longevity and safety.

Best practices include:

• Storing toys separately to prevent material reactions

• Using breathable fabric pouches

• Keeping everything cool, dry, and out of direct sunlight

A well-organized sex toy box protects your investment and keeps everything ready for spontaneous exploration.

5. Tools for Communication and Aftercare

A sex toy box can also support emotional connection.

Consider including:

• A yes/no/maybe checklist

• A small notebook for fantasies or reflections

• Comfort items like wipes, socks, or a soft blanket

• Lotions and massage oils

These extras encourage check-ins, aftercare, and honest dialogue—especially helpful when exploring something new.

What Not to Keep in a Sex Toy Box

Unsafe or Mystery Materials

Avoid toys made from:

• Jelly rubber

• Porous plastics

• Unlabeled materials

If you can’t clean it thoroughly, it doesn’t belong in your box.

Oil-Based Lubes (With Most Toys)

Oil-based products can degrade silicone and aren’t condom-safe. Unless a toy explicitly allows it, oil-based lubes are better left out of your main collection.

Dirty or "Later" Toys

Waiting to clean toys later increases bacteria growth. If something can’t be cleaned promptly, it’s better not to use it until you can give it proper care.

Guilt, Pressure, or Obligation

Your sex toy box should never make you feel behind, inadequate, or pressured to perform. Pleasure is personal—and your collection should reflect what you enjoy, not what you think you should.

Using Your Sex Toy Box for Exploration

Exploration works best when it’s intentional.

Try:

• Introducing one new toy or product at a time

• Pairing toys with plenty of lube and patience

• Checking in afterward about what felt good or didn’t

Remember: curiosity is more important than outcomes.

Shopping Smarter for Sex Toys Online

When browsing sex toys online:

• Read reviews with an eye toward comfort and care

• Look for educational retailers

• Choose products that support safety, not shortcuts

The best sex toys are the ones that respect your body.

Featured Products Wrap-Up

If you’re building or refreshing your sex toy box, these essentials deserve a permanent place:

• Wicked Sensual Aqua: A smooth, versatile water-based lubricant that enhances comfort and sensation across toys and bodies.

• Bang! Thrusting and Sucking Rabbit Vibrator. Blends tradition with innovation for a uniquely satisfying experience. 

• Triple Spire Tapered Silicone Anal Trainer Set. Helps you build comfort and confidence — one smooth, satisfying step at a time.

• Sliquid Naturals H2O: A sensitive-skin-friendly lube with a clean ingredient profile and long-lasting glide.

• Foaming Smart Sex Toy Cleaner: A simple, effective way to protect your toys—and your health—after every use.

Together, these products support safer play, better sensation, and more confident exploration.

A sex toy box should feel like an invitation—not a rulebook. When you prioritize consent, communicate openly, and care for your toys with the same attention you give your pleasure, exploration becomes easier and more rewarding.

Stock it with intention, clean it with care, and don’t forget the lube. Your body—and your toys—will thank you.